The 2009 FCS Portfolio Awards Judging Panel includes creative directors as well as senior level marketing executives from financial corporations:

- John  Derbick, Met Life
- Katy  Frohling-Railey, Wells Fargo
- Peggy  Johnson, formerly Smith Barney
- Patricia (Pat)  McGuire, Draft FCB
- David  Merrill, Deloitte
- Livingston  Miller, Seiter & Miller
- Brendán  Murphy, Lippincott
- Simon  Nickson, Euro RSCG
- Kevin  O'Donnehue, Y&R
- Blake  Olson, The Concept Farm
- John  Paolini, Sullivan
- Beth  Pasciucco, Morgan Stanley
- Maggie  Powers, Doremus
- Jeff  Spiegel, DDB Los Angeles
- Lee  St. James, Publicis
- Carole  Weitz, HNW
- Marge  Wyrwas, Knight Capital